Here is a few problems with a no carb diet
1. Expensive - The no carb diet like Atkins is expensive to buy food for. How much steak and chicken can you eat? There is no fiber to fill you and you just feel bloated from eating this expensive food all the time.
2. No Carb Diet is Boring - The no carb diet are boring as they just make you eat the same foods often and you never get the interesting foods like fruits and veggies that are high in carbs.
3. Not long term effective - A no carb diet will help you lose a few pounds initially but you do plateau after a while and then you are stuck trying to find another way to lose weight.
As far as diets go the no carb diet is just another kind of fad diet in my book. They seem to work but after a while you find it is not a good lifestyle change. Now we have other diets that are somewhat the same in the first place. I know that the Zone diet will focus in the induction phase for no carbs but then after the first couple of weeks you add carbs in and it is a lot more healthy, it's that induction part that always makes me nervous.
No Carb Diet. A Problem?
There are many ways to lose weight but the no carb diet is not a very good one in the long term
Have you done Atkins or something like it? Did a no carb diet work for you?